Welcome to Cousin Vinny's Pizza
Cousin Vinny's Pizza, located at 1513 W McGalliard Rd, Muncie, IN, is a beloved take-out spot renowned for its delicious, affordable pizzas. Patrons rave about the consistently fresh, piping hot offerings that are ready ahead of time for pick-up, or delivered directly across town with friendly service. Their enticing deals, including a medium pizza combo and a rewarding loyalty program, make dining here a fantastic choice. Customers appreciate the professionalism of the staff, making each visit a pleasant experience. With rave reviews suggesting that Vinny's delivers on taste and value, it's clear this pizzeria is a local favorite.
Cousin Vinny's Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
Really good pizza at less cost than most.
Usually grab their pizza when it's 50% off and grab it for take-out, but grabbed delivery this evening. We have done so previously and it's always on the spot on and their employees are always professional and courteous. Plus they deliver across town, which is a Plus for me. We always tip accordingly for the service.
Gave us free pizza 10/10
We love their pizza! It's always still piping hot when it's delivered, and it's always ready early when I'm picking up (I literally order and then leave right away.) They have a deal for a medium pizza, breadsticks, and 2 drinks which runs me about 23 with extra toppings, delivery, tax, and tip (I believe it's just 13.50 if you don't add stuff.) If I pick up, I can usually get out of there for a little over 12 with their carryout deal. Their 20 oz. drinks come in reusable cups, which they change every season. It's silly, but we really enjoy that. They also have a rewards program, so we have enough points for a free pizza about every 6th time we order. It's just a take-out store, so there's not a lot of ambiance, but it always smells great in there. The staff is really friendly. The delivery drivers are also very pleasant (even the time my dogs got out - they just wanted to say hi, but they're big dogs, and it was probably scary. He kept it together like a pro!) I highly recommend.
DINNER AND A SHOW!!! Less than an hours wait on Christmas Eve. Got to watch a worker snap in the kitchen. The pizza was fantastic. Will be back for New Years Eve.
We have always wanted to try Cousin Vinny's. We gave them a shot a few weeks back and have not been disappointed. We have ordered multiple times over the past few weeks. Every time it has exceeded our expectations. They have truly the best pizza in town and has never been short on toppings. I highly recommend the Family Meal deal! Huge thanks to everyone, we will be back again soon!
I must say, there is some new staff and they are much much better!! I truly appreciated their customer service anf helping me decide on a sub. They suggested the veggie revival with carolina gold sauce.....AMAZING!!! THANKS GUYS!
We love this place everything we've had has been awesome one complaint is the hours because I could really use some pizza for lunch from them but love the late night hours that is a plus but maybe like 1pm -1am
Location
-
1513 W McGalliard Rd, Muncie, IN 47304, United States Hotline: +1 765-281-1000
Welcome to the delicious world of Cousin Vinny's Pizza, a beloved take-out haven nestled at 1513 W McGalliard Rd, Muncie, IN. Known for its fantastic pizzas and inviting customer service, this spot has quickly become a staple for many locals and visitors alike.
The essence of Cousin Vinny's shines through in their commitment to both quality and affordability. Customers rave about the great taste paired with an affordable price, making it a go-to option for pizza lovers seeking value without compromising flavor. One frequent patron, James Danforth, aptly summed it up: “Really good pizza at less cost than most.” Just imagine indulging in a warm, cheesy slice without breaking the bank!
But it doesn’t stop there. Many customers appreciate the convenience of their well-organized delivery service. Glen Peckinpaugh shared his experience, remarking on the courteous and professional staff that make ordering a breeze. For those who prefer to pick up, the pizzas are always ready early, ensuring you can dive into dinner as soon as possible. Plus, with delicious deals like a medium pizza, breadsticks, and drinks for just over $23, Cousin Vinny's makes it easier to feed the family.
The ambiance may be minimal—more focused on efficiency than décor—but the delightful aroma of freshly baked pizzas welcomes you the moment you walk in. Diners like Jenny Willenberg have highlighted the thoughtful touches, such as the seasonal reusable drink cups and the rewarding loyalty program that nets you a free pizza every few orders. It’s the little things that count, and Cousin Vinny's seems to understand that perfectly.
Even on busy nights, like Christmas Eve, customers have received their orders with great efficiency, as noted by Chris Beard. Despite a minor hiccup in the kitchen, he found the overall experience—including the pizza itself—fantastic. It’s these stories of resilience and community that draw people, giving life to the notion of “dinner and a show.”
Cousin Vinny's Pizza not only delights with its flavor but also fosters a welcoming environment that keeps customers coming back. Whether you're after a quick bite or planning a cozy family dinner at home, this pizza gem has you covered. So next time you're in Muncie, treat yourself to a slice or two—your taste buds will thank you!